- Home
- News
- Die Casting Mold Steel Selection Roadmap H13 vs P20 vs Hardened vs Pre-Hardened for Production Volume
Die Casting Mold Steel Selection Roadmap H13 vs P20 vs Hardened vs Pre-Hardened for Production Volume
Content Menu
● Hardened Versus Pre-Hardened
● Q&A
Introduction
When working on die casting projects, one of the first decisions that comes up is which steel to use for the mold. The choice affects everything from initial costs to how long the tool will last in production. H13, P20, and variations like hardened or pre-hardened versions each have their place depending on the expected volume and the alloy being cast.
Die casting pushes molds hard with high pressures, fast injection speeds, and big temperature swings. Molten metal hits the cavity walls hot, then cools quickly, creating cycles that can lead to cracking or wear over time. Getting the steel wrong means more repairs, shorter runs, or even full replacements sooner than planned.
H13 stands out for its ability to handle heat without losing strength. P20 offers easier machining and lower upfront costs. Hardened steels go through full heat treatment for peak performance in tough spots, while pre-hardened come ready at a set hardness level, skipping some steps.
This guide looks at these options side by side, with focus on production volumes—from small batches to full-scale runs. We’ll cover properties, real shop examples, and trade-offs. For instance, a shop running aluminum parts for automotive might start with pre-hardened P20 for prototypes, then move to hardened H13 for hundreds of thousands of shots. Another doing zinc hardware could stick with P20 longer because temperatures stay lower.
The goal here is a straightforward path to pick the best fit, based on what works in practice and backed by studies on thermal fatigue and tool life.
Mold Demands in Die Casting
Die casting molds face a mix of stresses no other tooling matches. The process fills the cavity with metal under pressure, often aluminum at 650-700°C or zinc lower around 400°C. Each shot heats the surface fast, then spray and cooling bring it down, repeating thousands of times.
Core Properties Needed
Resistance to thermal fatigue tops the list—those repeated expansions and contractions cause fine cracks called heat checking. Wear from the flowing metal erodes edges, especially in gates and runners. Toughness prevents gross cracking under ejection forces or clamping.
Hardness matters for wear, but too high can make the steel brittle. Thermal conductivity helps pull heat away, reducing peak temperatures.
Volume Drives the Choice
Low volumes, say a few thousand parts, prioritize quick machining and low cost. Medium runs balance that with better durability. High volumes demand steels that hold up over 100,000+ cycles to keep per-part costs down.
One shop casting small zinc fittings used pre-hardened steel for initial orders under 20,000 pieces. When volumes grew, they switched inserts to hardened material. Another producing aluminum housings for electronics went straight to H13 for runs pushing 300,000, avoiding early failures seen with milder steels.
H13 Steel Details
H13, a hot-work tool steel, gets used widely in die casting because it stays tough at high temperatures.
Makeup and Treatment
It has around 5% chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium for carbide formation that keeps hardness hot. Typical treatment: quench from over 1000°C, then temper to 45-52 HRC.
Shops often double temper to relieve stresses. In one case, a caster for magnesium parts tempered H13 cores to 50 HRC, getting consistent life over 150,000 shots.
Strengths for Die Work
Thermal fatigue resistance comes from its alloying—it softens less above 500°C than other steels. In aluminum casting, this means fewer heat checks.
A transmission parts supplier ran full H13 molds for over 400,000 aluminum shots with minimal polishing needed. For zinc, the same steel handled abrasive flow better, lasting twice as long as alternatives in hardware production.
Downsides and Workarounds
Machining hardened H13 takes longer and wears tools faster. Many machine it soft, then treat. A bicycle component maker did this, cutting time while still hitting high-volume needs.
Cost runs higher, but pays back in long runs. For short prototypes, it can feel like overkill.
P20 Steel Overview
P20 serves as a go-to for plastic molds but sees use in die casting where demands stay milder.
Composition and Supply
Lower alloy—chromium and molybdenum for polishability, delivered pre-hardened around 30-35 HRC.
Variants add elements for better toughness. A lighting fixture shop machined P20 directly for zinc dies, skipping treatment delays.
Fit for Volumes
Best in medium runs with lower heat alloys. Magnesium or zinc often work fine up to 80,000 cycles.
A medical parts caster used P20 for aluminum batches around 30,000, keeping costs down. In hotter aluminum work, soldering appeared early, pushing them to upgrade.
Machining and Economics
Pre-hardened means faster cutting, less distortion risk. A custom hardware producer finished P20 molds quicker than treated H13, suiting varied small orders.
Coatings help extend life—one lock maker added nitride, pushing cycles higher.
Hardened Steels in Practice
Full hardening after machining pushes hardness to maximum for wear-heavy areas.
Treatment Steps
Machine soft, austenitize, quench, temper to 48-55 HRC. Distortion control is key.
Cores in pump housings got hardened H13, surviving abrasive aluminum flow for 250,000+ shots.
High-Stress Uses
Slides and inserts benefit most. Wheel casters hardened cavity areas to fight pressure cracks in million-shot tools.
For prototypes, treatment adds time, but production demands it. A toy zinc caster hardened select zones for balanced cost.
Distortion Issues
Quenching warps parts sometimes. Vacuum methods help—one enclosure producer kept tolerances tight this way.
Pre-Hardened Options
These arrive at usable hardness, ready for machining without final treat.
Speed Advantages
Around 32-40 HRC, cuts easily. Prototype shops use them for fast die casting trials.
A consumer goods caster iterated aluminum tests quickly with pre-hardened blocks.
Limits in Heat
Softens faster in hot work. Zinc fittings ran fine to 100,000, but aluminum needed upgrades early.
Hardware latches saw good life without issues in cooler runs.
H13 Versus P20 Head-to-Head
Heat and Wear
H13 holds hardness better hot—up to 550°C versus P20 dropping sooner. Aluminum life often doubles or more.
An engine parts shop saw P20 fail at 120,000, H13 go to 450,000.
P20 saves money in zinc or magnesium.
Machining Time
Pre-hardened P20 finishes faster. One firm cut days off custom zinc work.
Cost Over Life
H13 starts higher but lowers per-part in volume. 300,000-piece run: H13 mold cheaper overall than multiple P20.
Hardened Versus Pre-Hardened
Hardened for endurance in production; pre-hardened for rapid starts.
Lower Volumes
Pre-hardened speeds trials. 8,000-piece aluminum tests avoided waits.
Higher Volumes
Hardened prevents breakdowns. 180,000-cycle pumps needed it.
Aerospace magnesium went pre-hardened prototypes, hardened production.
Hybrids common—pre-hardened blocks, hardened inserts in trim casting.
Selection Roadmap by Volume
Under 10,000 Shots
Pre-hardened P20 or similar for speed. Custom prototypes machined fast.
Hot alloys? H13 inserts.
10,000 to 100,000
P20 or improved pre-hardened. Zinc housings economical at 60,000.
Over 100,000
Hardened H13 standard. Automotive housings hit millions.
Alloy matters—aluminum pushes H13, zinc allows flexibility.
Other Considerations
Cooling design critical for H13. Coatings boost any.
Longer life cuts waste.
Trends Moving Forward
Conformal cooling via printing helps H13. Nitriding extends surfaces.
One caster printed channels in bases, gaining cycles.
Conclusion
Choosing mold steel for die casting boils down to matching material to volume and conditions. H13 delivers where heat and cycles dominate, lasting far longer in aluminum high-volume work as shops have found in transmission and wheel production. P20 fits medium runs or lower-heat alloys, offering machining ease and savings seen in zinc hardware and magnesium parts. Hardened versions maximize resistance in demanding zones, while pre-hardened speed up low-volume or prototype phases.
Those real cases—a bracket maker moving from P20 tests to H13 production, or hybrid setups in fittings—show how the choices flex. Lifecycle costs, including repairs and downtime, often favor tougher steels as runs grow. Simulate loads if unsure, test batches, talk suppliers.
This roadmap gives a solid base, adaptable to specific setups. Good selection keeps tools running longer, parts consistent, operations smooth.
Q&A
Q: Why does H13 outperform P20 in aluminum die casting?
A: Better hot hardness and fatigue resistance delay cracking, often doubling life in high-heat cycles.
Q: Is pre-hardened steel suitable for production runs?
A: Yes for low to medium volumes or prototypes, offering fast machining without treatment delays.
Q: How does volume affect justifying H13 costs?
A: Over 100,000 shots, extended life lowers overall expenses despite higher initial outlay.
Q: Does P20 work well in any die casting?
A: Effective for zinc or magnesium medium runs, where lower temperatures reduce wear demands.
Q: What hybrid steel strategies help?
A: Pre-hardened bodies with hardened H13 inserts balance speed, cost, and durability.