CNC Machining cutting speed selection matching feed rates to material hardness for optimal tool life

precision cnc machining

Content Menu

● Introduction

● Cutting Speed and Feed Rate Fundamentals

● How Hardness Changes the Game

● Wear Mechanisms Tied to Hardness and Speed

● Practical Speed Selection Rules

● Feed Rate Adjustments That Actually Work

● Real Shop Examples

● Advanced Tweaks When Volume Justifies It

● Common Mistakes That Kill Tools Fast

● Conclusion

 

Introduction

In any shop that runs CNC machines day in and day out, the single biggest variable that quietly controls tool life, surface finish, and overall cost per part is how well the cutting speed and feed rate match the actual hardness of the material in front of the spindle. Most programmers start with the numbers printed in the tool catalog, but the moment the workpiece hardness drifts outside the “average” range the catalog assumes, tool life can drop by half—or double—depending on whether the adjustment goes the right way or the wrong way.

Hardness affects everything: heat generation, chip formation, cutting forces, and every major wear mechanism on the tool edge. This article walks through exactly how to read hardness, how to translate it into practical speed and feed numbers, and how to verify the choices on the machine. The goal is simple—leave the shift with sharp tools, good parts, and no surprises.

Cutting Speed and Feed Rate Fundamentals

Cutting speed (Vc) is the linear velocity of the tool edge against the workpiece, usually given in surface feet per minute (SFM) or meters per minute (m/min). Feed rate is the distance the tool advances per minute (IPM or mm/min), which comes from feed per tooth, number of flutes, and spindle rpm.

The two numbers are linked through chip thickness. Run the spindle too fast for the hardness and the temperature at the shear zone climbs past the point where the carbide or coating stays stable. Run the feed too slow and the edge rubs instead of cutting, work-hardens the surface, and still kills the tool—just more slowly.

On a 3-inch face mill in 1018 steel, for example, 900 SFM with 0.006 in/tooth is a safe starting point. The same cutter in 4140 pre-hard at 32 Rc needs closer to 450 SFM and 0.005 in/tooth to stay in the same wear regime. Ignore that drop and the inserts are rounded over before the first pallet is done.

high precision cnc machining

How Hardness Changes the Game

Hardness is resistance to plastic deformation. Higher hardness means higher shear strength, higher cutting forces, and more heat for the same volume removed. In carbon and low-alloy steels, every 100 HB increase typically requires roughly a 25–35 % drop in cutting speed with carbide tools to keep flank wear under control.

In stainless grades the relationship is steeper because of lower thermal conductivity—heat stays in the cutting zone longer. Titanium alloys behave differently; the hardness itself is moderate (320–380 HV), but the low modulus and high chemical reactivity make them act like much harder materials unless speeds are kept low.

A job shop running 17-4 PH stainless at 35–38 Rc found that staying above 180 SFM with a 0.500-inch end mill produced beautiful chips for the first two minutes, then rapid cratering. Dropping to 140 SFM and raising feed per tooth from 0.0035 to 0.0055 in/tooth gave three times the corner life and a better surface.

Wear Mechanisms Tied to Hardness and Speed

At low hardness (< 200 HB) the dominant wear is usually abrasion from carbides or inclusions plus mild adhesion. Once hardness climbs past 30 Rc, diffusion wear and thermal softening of the binder phase in carbide become the limiting factors. Above 45 Rc, micro-chipping and plastic deformation of the cutting edge often take over.

A set of turning tests on AISI 4340 quenched and tempered to 45 Rc showed that flank wear rate doubled for every 50 SFM increase above 120 SFM when using coated carbide. The same inserts at 90 SFM and slightly higher feed (0.012 in/rev) lasted twice as long with almost no cratering.

cnc machining titanium

Practical Speed Selection Rules

Start with the manufacturer’s recommended speed for the “average” hardness of the alloy, then apply a correction factor:

  • 150–250 HB → 90–100 % of catalog speed
  • 250–350 HB → 65–80 % of catalog speed
  • 35–45 Rc → 45–60 % of catalog speed
  • 50–60 Rc → 25–40 % of catalog speed (often switch to CBN or ceramic)

For aluminum alloys the range is much narrower because hardness rarely exceeds 160 HB, but heat-treated 7000 series can still demand 15–20 % lower speed than 6061 to avoid built-up edge.

Feed Rate Adjustments That Actually Work

Feed per tooth should decrease as hardness increases, but not linearly. The goal is to keep the maximum uncut chip thickness roughly constant so the shear angle stays favorable.

A working guideline used on many floors:

  • < 200 HB → 0.006–0.012 in/tooth (roughing)
  • 250–350 HB → 0.004–0.008 in/tooth
  • 35–45 Rc → 0.003–0.006 in/tooth

  • 50 Rc → 0.0015–0.004 in/tooth or switch to constant-pressure strategies

In 1045 steel at 220 HB, a 1/2-inch four-flute end mill at 600 SFM and 0.0045 in/tooth (360 IPM) produced 0.0008 inch flank wear after 60 minutes. The same job at 42 Rc needed 300 SFM and 0.0038 in/tooth (180 IPM) to reach the same wear land in 55 minutes—still respectable metal removal rate and far better tool cost.

cnc machining steel

Real Shop Examples

Example 1 – Mold shop roughing H13 at 48–50 Rc with 1-inch inserted milling cutter Original parameters: 220 SFM, 0.004 in/tooth, 55 IPM Result: inserts chipped after 8 minutes New parameters: 130 SFM, 0.0055 in/tooth, 45 IPM Result: 38 minutes per insert, smoother run, no chipping

Example 2 – Aerospace house slotting Ti-6Al-4V (360 HV) with 3/8-inch five-flute Catalog said 160 SFM, 0.0025 in/tooth Actual run at catalog numbers gave 11 minutes before notch wear Reduced to 110 SFM, increased to 0.0038 in/tooth → 42 minutes per tool and cleaner slots

Example 3 – Production line facing 6061-T6 extrusions that occasionally contained 7075-T6 scraps Fixed 950 SFM, 0.010 in/tooth worked fine on 6061 but caused immediate edge buildup on 7075 Solution: dropped to 750 SFM universally, kept same feed → consistent 2-hour cutter life across mixed pallets

Advanced Tweaks When Volume Justifies It

Shops running the same hardness day after day often build their own speed/feed tables from wear tests. A simple ladder test—run four identical features at 80 %, 100 %, 120 %, and 140 % of calculated speed, measure flank wear with a toolmaker’s scope, plot the curve—takes less than an hour and pays for itself on the first pallet.

Modern controllers with adaptive control or load monitoring can automatically back feed off when hardness spikes (common in forgings or weld-repaired castings) and return to full feed when the zone clears.

Common Mistakes That Kill Tools Fast

  • Using aluminum speeds on heat-treated 7000 series because “it’s still aluminum”
  • Keeping the same feed per tooth when dropping speed on hard material—guarantees rubbing
  • Ignoring coolant concentration; 5 % synthetic is fine for mild steel, disastrous above 40 Rc
  • Programming constant RPM instead of constant SFM on turning centers when diameter changes

Conclusion

Matching cutting speed and feed rate to the real hardness sitting in the vise is one of the highest-leverage adjustments any CNC shop can make. The rules are straightforward, the payback is immediate, and the data needed—hardness number, tool catalog baseline, and a few test cuts—are already within reach on most floors. Start conservative, measure wear, adjust once, and lock the proven numbers into your setup sheets or CAM tool library. Do that consistently and tool life stops being a mystery and starts becoming one more controlled variable in an increasingly predictable process.